Baked Oysters with Roasted Tomatoes

A baked oyster is a very, very fine appetizer for any meal but especially one that craves some festivity.

Baked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes Baked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes

Forget everything you’ve ever thought about oysters–that they must be eaten raw, that you’re too weak to shuck them, head to your favorite local fishmonger, open a bottle of wine (before you even start cooking), and let’s bake some oysters!

The reason you should open the bottle of wine–here, K-J AVANT Chardonnay, whose body and hint of fruit-forward flavors goes so well with the roasted tomatoes and the seafood (if you like your oysters raw, then you’ll want to pair those with the Kendall-Jackson AVANT Sauvignon Blanc — it pairs so perfectly!) –is that you’re going to have to teach yourself to shuck oysters at home. This isn’t hard, but it could take a couple of attempts. Here’s a demo of how to shuck an oyster. Don’t get frustrated! Once you get one oyster unhinged, it all becomes kind of fun.

Baked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes Baked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes

Oh, and while you’re carefully shucking, you’ll also be roasting whole peeled tomatoes from a can so that they turn jammy and sweet and nearly taste like summer. Make extra if this sounds delicious to you: you’ll want them on pasta and sandwiches, not just on oysters.

Anyway, if you’re shucking-challenged, your time is still not wasted.

Baked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes

The shucked, tomato-topped, butter-gilded oysters then cook on a bed of salt. That helps keep each shell upright and all the juices, which taste like the sea, inside.

When they’re done, you’ll see the tomatoes becoming even more jammy, and the oysters curling up off the sides of their shells.

Baked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes #KJAVANTBaked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes

That’s the time to pour new glasses of K-J AVANT Chardonnay and dig in.

Baked Oysters Topped with Roasted Tomatoes


Baked Oysters with Roasted Tomatoes
Recipe type: Appetizer
Cuisine: American
Serves: 2
Just a few ingredients turn oysters into an addictive and festive dinner party appetizer. This recipe is easily doubled or tripled to serve a crowd.
  • One 14.5 ounce can whole peeled tomatoes, juice drained and reserved for another purpose, like making a Bloody Mary
  • 3 cloves whole garlic
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 6 oysters, shucked
  • About ¾ cup kosher salt
  • 2 tablespoons butter
  • Lemon wedges for garnish
  1. Preheat the oven to 400°F. Combine the tomatoes, garlic, and olive oil in a small pan, then place in the oven. Roast for about 45 minutes, until the garlic is golden and the tomatoes are blackened in places. You'll only use 1 or 2 tomatoes in this dish, so reserve any extras for eating on crostini or mixing in with pasta.
  2. Turn the oven to broil. Take a 9-by-9 inch baking pan and arrange the salt in the bottom. Place the oysters in the salt, using the salt to support them so they don't fall over and lose their juices. Mince two of the whole tomatoes and dollop them on top of each oyster. Cut the butter into little wedges and scatter them on the oysters.
  3. Place on the top level of the oven and broil for about 6 minutes, until the oysters have shrunken a bit and the edges are brown. Serve immediately on a plate garnished with lemon wedges.